Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lee Penman's avatar

I can most certainly be an oversharer. I am unsure if this is a byproduct of living most of my life alone. I have tried to be better, though I am still a work in progress. Right now, I am dealing with a health problem with my little bird Rico, and it has taken a lot not to ask everyone with a pulse for advice:)

My friend is a doctor, and I help her manage her schedule and patients on a daily basis. One thing I have noticed is the rapport she forms with her patients and the way they feel they can talk to her about anything and everything. I think it is good to have a medical professional who is not condescending and guides you rather than instructs you.

Again, your sharing this is admirable as it is REAL and so many people find it hard to be real these days.

Anyway, before I enter rambling mode, I will return to my little situation here and will revisit this post again later as it deserves more than one read:)

Expand full comment
Yoshi Watanabe's avatar

I read it with great interest.

Recently, a music band mentioned "advice uncles" as one of their dislikes. Apparently, these people give them unsolicited advice whenever they have any complaints about the band. This overlaps with what you wrote.

These "advice uncles" seem to forget that people can only truly change when they seek it themselves, and even then, it should only be a suggestion. They get overwhelmed by their own dissatisfaction and blame others for it. This is a point I can make with self-reflection as well.

The "should" argument is troublesome. It's like applying the future perfect tense from English grammar to others. The future perfect is normal as a personal thought pattern, but in the second person, it tends to become a command. Modern social media tends to give advice while ignoring the recipient's background, context, existing knowledge, and education.

Those are my impressions.

Expand full comment
46 more comments...

No posts